This post explores lagoon wastewater treatment replacement and retrofit options for small communities faced with stringent NPDES treatment requirements. It also includes an overview of disinfection options for lagoon and mechanical wastewater treatment systems.
Stringent & Evolving NPDES Permit Limits Protect the Environment
Small communities with aerated lagoon and facultative controlled discharge lagoon wastewater treatment systems are facing increasingly stringent treatment requirements for ammonia, pH, dissolved oxygen, and bacteria with new National Pollution Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permits. Permit limit changes have been driven by the need to protect the quality of our environment and water supply. Required by the EPA, DNR, and/or other state regulatory agencies, the permit is authorized under the Clean Water Act for the regulation of point sources that discharge pollutants into U.S. waters.
Ammonia is a natural by-product of the decomposition of all nitrogen-containing organic matter. This means it’s something we all contribute to because the human body produces ammonia. Industrial users, such as food processing, fertilizer, and dog food plants, also contribute to ammonia levels, but in higher concentrations.
Ammonia promotes algae growth in bodies of water and it’s converted to nitrite and nitrate through aerobic biological activity depleting dissolved oxygen in water. At elevated concentrations, this can be lethal to aquatic life and some algae can even be toxic to humans.
“Meeting these requirements is essential to protect the environment and our water supply, which is the most valuable resource we have, for future generations,” states Lindsay Beaman, PE, Business Unit Leader of Snyder & Associates’ Cedar Rapids office.
Lagoon Systems Struggle to Meet New Ammonia Limits
To effectively treat ammonia in lagoons it requires nitrifying bacteria and an environment where the bacteria can thrive. The success of aerated and facultative lagoons in removing ammonia is limited to moderate-temperature weather. Once the water temperature dips below 40 degrees Fahrenheit, the bacteria needed to treat ammonia become inactive. As a result, many small, Midwestern communities need alternative solutions for ammonia reduction that can withstand cold winter temperatures.
The goal of new NPDES permit limits for pH is to ensure discharged water has a similar pH to the receiving stream. PH is a vital factor as it keeps everything in balance, creating a healthy environment where aquatic life can flourish. If the pH becomes too acidic or basic, aquatic plants and organisms are negatively impacted.
Disinfection, the third component of new NPDES permit limits, is essential because bacteria, protozoa, and viruses present in water can lead to disease and illness. Even just a single exposure can have hazardous health effects.
Evaluation of Technologies Used to Reduce Ammonia
For small livable communities seeking alternative methods of ammonia reduction, the solution is lagoon enhancement or replacement. Mechanical plant options exist for lagoon replacement, while Lemna systems, NitrOx® Reactor systems, and Submerged Attached Growth Reactor (SAGR) systems are common ways to enhance an existing lagoon.
Lagoon Replacement Options
AeroMod and Sequencing Batch Reactors (SBR) are two examples of mechanical plant options for lagoon replacement. Both systems utilize the activated biosolids process to treat wastewater.
The Atkins Wastewater Treatment Plant is an example of an AeroMod system used to achieve NPDES permit effluent limits, while expanding plant capacity to accommodate the increased influent flow.
Lagoon Enhancement or Retrofit Options
A LEMNA system utilizes modular, insulated covers to help retain heat. They also keep sunlight out, hindering algae growth, which can cause problems with suspended solids in the effluent. Nitrifying and denitrifying reactors are plug-in components added to the back of the lagoon to finish the process the lagoon starts. Overall, LEMNA systems are relatively easy to install with few moving parts and minimal human intervention needed for operation.
Currently, our team is designing a LEMNA treatment system for the City of Earling, IA, whose facility is at max capacity. Their lagoon system is landlocked with an unwilling seller around it, making expansion a difficult solution. The LEMNA system allows the City to maintain the current footprint while greatly increasing treatment capacity. Construction is expected to begin in 2021.
A NitrOx Reactor is a compact, easy to install system that enhances lagoon systems by heating the water to maintain the temperature needed to keep bacteria active. Situated next to a lagoon, these low-cost systems are relatively easy to maintain and operate. However, because the system helps regulate water temperature, utility costs will likely increase.
Norway’s Wastewater Treatment Plant improvement project utilizes a NitrOx Reactor. This was determined to be the best course of action because it can manage the ammonia removal process while still utilizing the existing aerated lagoon treatment system.
Submerged Attached Growth Reactor (SAGR)
Typically built as an addition to an existing lagoon, SAGR systems are an effective solution for meeting stringent EPA water quality standards in cold to moderate climates. They’re also fairly easy to operate and maintain. Constructed below grade, SAGR systems take advantage of natural, geothermal heat and the earth’s natural insulating properties to maintain water temperature during average winter conditions.
Supplemental Disinfection Options for Lagoon & Mechanical Wastewater Treatment
Regardless of which solution you choose, supplemental disinfection will be necessary to meet NPDES requirements.
Natural disinfection allows wastewater to sit exposed to the elements for approximately 180 days as bacteria die off. Without the need for chemicals, maintenance, and utilities, it’s affordable and easy to use. However, natural disinfection can’t be guaranteed, and it requires more space than other options.
This method of disinfection utilizes chemicals to disinfect wastewater. While effective, it requires space, labor, chemical use, and storage, which are factors communities should take into account. Another downside is the pass-through of chemicals into the receiving stream.
UV disinfection utilizes light to neutralize harmful microorganisms. UV systems come in many shapes and sizes, allowing them to be tailored to specific community needs. However, low light transmittance impairs the effectiveness of UV disinfection, so it’s not ideal for all lagoon systems.
Determining the Appropriate Ammonia Treatment Option
It’s also essential to take operator licensing into account. Whether you’re looking to upgrade or replace your wastewater treatment facility, you’ll need a licensed staff to operate it. Depending on how sophisticated yours will be, higher certification for operators may be required.
Many communities in need of lagoon enhancement or replacement are experiencing population decline, with much of the remaining population on fixed incomes. The burden of expensive wastewater treatment system initiatives is borne by the residents, often in situations where city rates haven’t increased for a long time. Our team has significant experience in assisting communities with grant and loan applications and appealing to the DNR for time extensions while affordable alternatives are explored. Once the appropriate solution is determined, project planning, permitting, and construction typically occurs over a five-year period.